Talk:So Many Birthdays/@comment-172.4.23.117-20140304225447/@comment-24.99.189.109-20140304231659

No, she was simply desperate. At that point, the Gems completely ran out of options to take, so Garnet had to resort to the unreasonable. Which is especially tragic seeing as though you'd never expect someone as stoic and collected as Garnet to completely crack under pressure. It goes to show how much she actually cared. She didn't want to "put him out of his misery", she wanted to save him just like Amethyst and Pearl wanted as well.