Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26539546-20150629010213

Many theories ahead. Also long. Very long.

1. Rose Quartz is Pink Diamond..?

Many users theorize Rose being Pink Diamond, one of the Diamond Quartet/Diamond Authority.

While it is a theory and anyone can theorize what they want, no matter how stupid or unreal it looks, I really don't support that theory too much. Like, okay, she's pink. Is that the sole reason? She's pink? According to that rule, then we can assume that Lapis is Blue Diamond, and Onion is White diamond. Right? Lapis is blue, and Onion is white! Totally legit!

Well, theory isn't theory unless there's proof. Their proof: Rose is pink. My proof against this theory:
 * 1) In Serious Steven, once the quartet enter the pyramid, this part of the pyramid temple is shown. During the pan, we can see this (editing by me):  http://orig12.deviantart.net/243e/f/2015/179/0/3/wow_by_iinnai-d8z5by1.png
 * Obviously enough, the qaurtet of diamonds are present, which makes Rose the odd one out. Pink Diamond is not shown by character, but her pink diamonds are shown, which is enough proof to me.

Also, a typical Rose Quartz gem isn't a diamond. Steven Universe follows basic gemstone knowledge/logic.

2. Sardonyx is the fusion of all Crystal Gems/The Temple

While this sounded believable to me at first, I kind of.. don't.. It just doesn't make sense anymore.
 * 1) This is the week of Sardonyx, meaning she will be present all week. Even if their fusion means the CGs are present, they have to be visible. It's common sense.
 * 2) I think if they all fused together, they'd be a few feet shorter than the Temple. Also, the temple doesn't really show the CGs fused together into one gem. On her forehead, there's a standalone Pearl. On the chest, ye olde Amethyst. The hands, well, Sapphire and Ruby's Garnet. On the stomach where the bellybutton be, Rose Quartz/Steven (but mostly Rose, hence the crazy curly hair). Once again, this could be just to state who inhabits the temple. But the crewniverse wouldn't just do that, in my opinion. They're advanced B)
 * 3) Maybe if the CGs fused, they wouldn't form Sardonyx. In my opinion, they might form Alexite, Ametrine or Padparadscha, which are gemstones stronger than Alexandrite.

3. Jasper is a fusion/Lapis is a fusion

Man, if that was the case, then that would be a hella stable fusion. They both have normal numbers of features, like 2 eyes, 1 mouth, 1 head, 2 arms, 2 legs, 5-6 feet tall.. etc. They also only have one gem placed on their body.

Althought Lapis is, surprisingly, stronger than Jasper (which is solely why many people believe in this theory), she seems to my a single Gem, not a fusion. Same goes with Jasper.

Unless Lapis/Jasper fused with a Gem that has no eyes, no mouth, no limbs, and a gemstone placed somewhere inappropriate, there's no way they're a fusion.

4. If Steven fused with Pearl, they'd form Rainbow Quartz!

No. They'd be highly unstable wouldn't look like the RQ we know at all. RQ with Steven would also be mighty shorter and would have a heavier build. She might not be as flexible too.

5. Connie is a Gem because she was able to fuse with Steven!

Nuh-uh. They only fused because a Gem (Steven's) was present. The human part of Steven collided with Connie, leaving the Rose Quartz gem to actually fuse them together.

Also, Connie isn't a gemstone's name.

6. Sardonyx is Malachite but with Jasper in control

Noooooo. It doesn't matter who's in control. Whats important is the form and presence of the fusing gems. For example, if you mixed 2 eggs with 1 cup of flour and put in the oven, it's (a poor excuse for) cake, right? But, if you put 1 egg with 2 cups of flour, it's going to be a bit more dry. But it's still (not really) cake, no?

Same thing with fusions. If Lapis is in charge, the result is a personality that wants to prevent itself from destroying further. But if Jasper takes place, the personality will be altered, but it's still Malachite, no?

Did anything happen to Alexandrite when the trio began to argue? Did they become Iolite? Nah, is cool.

The only theory I truly believe in is, that Malachite is now unfused under the ocean, yet they are still trapped under Lapis's will.

The reason why I believe in this, is because Malachite, when put in water, becomes toxic, which affects Lapis's control on Malachite, but does not disable her. So due to Malachite being under Jasper's control, they of course had to argue and ultimately causing them to unfuse (because disagreement that happens between the two can cause them to defuse. And yes, they can disagree and defuse because Malachite didn't get to become one person, or have one personality, because the fusion is unstable, and both gems have different intentions.)

Damn, this is long, and I'm kinda tired now.  