Talk:Smoky Quartz/@comment-24378910-20170209203328/@comment-5642360-20170214222219

Thinking may not be the same way as knowing but since Steven doesn't have Rose's memories. Smoky's memories are halved since Amethyst is the only one who knows who she is, hence why Smoky said "I feel like Amethyst knows this."

Also, going back to what David said. Smoky's line "I think a Rose Quartz and an Amethyst make a Smoky Quartz." implies that any Amethyst and Rose Quartz that fuse will become a Smoky Quartz. Their dialog said "a Rose Quartz" and "an Amethyst", they didn't say "I think Rose Quartz and Amethyst make a Smoky Quartz." Using the indefinite articles "a" and "an" implies that there is no specific Rose or Amethyst Gem, and that any could become Smoky.

Also, Steven's human side only affects appearance (and Steven himself affecting personality). Steven's human side doesn't affect the Gem outcome. When Steven and Connie fuse, their Gemstone is still a Rose Quartz, it didn't change. Steven as a Rose Quartz (doesn't matter if he's part human) and Amethyst as an Amethyst would make a Smoky Quartz. But since Steven is technically a different person/gem and human, this Smoky would be new and different.