Talk:Your Mother and Mine/@comment-5406733-20180411181530/@comment-32531832-20180411213017

I have three theories about what really happened: 1) Rose pretended to shatter Pink Diamond and then bubbled her away somewhere; 2) Pink Diamond conspired with Rose to fake her death and then got hit by the Corrupting Light; 3) White Diamond shattered Pink Diamond and then used mind-control powers to make all the witnesses (including Rose herself, and possibly Garnet as well) believe that Rose had done it, not realizing that Rose's sword isn't capable of shattering Gems. All of these theories are compatible with what we know at this point. But I don't think Garnet is knowlingly saying anything untrue in this episode.