Talk:Pink Diamond/@comment-25274978-20160808233959

Ok gonna put this out there and whoever wants to be mad at me for pointing it out, is more then welcome to be but here we go.

I don't understand how anyone could have thought Pink Diamond and Rose Quartz were the same Gem, yes they can shape shift but they cannot change their gems. Amethyst shifts into Peridot or pearl but her gem is still there. And you cannot change the shaping of your Gem so, while Diamond might be some sort of quartz or not IDK, it would not work.

I think Rose either poofed or was forced to shatter Pink Diamond: Or bubbled her away somewhere at some point for whatever reason. Yes she served under her as something at one point but clearly with the rebellion not anymore. There are theory's that basically say maybe Pink Diamond was part of the rebellion but then the Beta kindergarten wouldn't make sense since the gems that were there were supposed to work for homeworld, not for the rebellion.

So that's my thought on that but now I pose a question that is probably obvious:

Where'd the other Beta or even Alpha kindergarteners go? Like I assume a bunch were used for the Gem Mutants or even in the Cluster, some probably corrupted and others shattered- but did the rest go back to Homeworld like Jasper? ALSO

Mostly the Rose is NOT Pink Diamond thing, honestly I've been waiting for that to be proven wrong since the theory popped up the first time around.

Thank you writers and Jasper for doing that.