Talk:Your Mother and Mine/@comment-5406733-20180411181530/@comment-3225961-20180412124647

Okay, but where are these assumptions coming from, specifically:

"If she had started to see what Rose had seen in organics and change her mind about building the colony and destroying them"

and "practically tells us that Pink Diamond is still alive"?

If you're going to make these claims, you need to back them up with support, as what you have right now is a surmise. Don't forget that she was not a child, and she asked specifically to "command a dropship", not "I want you to appreciate me like the rest of the Diamonds". Her reasoning to have all these things was "I'm just as important as you".

As I said in the previous post, Garnet joined the Rebellion in The Answer, so we have no reason to believe that Garnet witnessed the events prior to that and thus could be intentionally lying about it. Someone, likely Rose, told her about Rose's origins, so why the need to ad hominem Garnet?

Garnet's story does not prove or disprove Pink Diamond's shattering; the fact that Gems claim to have witnessed it suggests that she was shattered. Why would two of the three Diamonds be so distraught about her shattering if they didn't care? We also don't have persuasive evidence that Pink Diamond was the sympathetic being you believe she was. So far the only thing you've mentioned is human zoo, but there is more to the zoo than meets the eye.