Talk:The Trial/@comment-32149481-20170530015154

 This is a theory based on the new episode of Steven Universe “The Trial” and mainly based on the blue Zircons reasoning. The Theory is that White Diamond wanted the rebellion to stop, and the other diamonds would not take action. So White Diamond Shattered Pink Diamond and blamed it on Rose Quartz. The reason I believe this is all based on what Zircon said in The Trial. Zircon states that based on the fact that Pink Diamond was standing out of her Palanquin and that her Pearl, Agates and other protective Gems would have protected her. Her Sapphires would also know of the attack and tell her. This means that PD had to be addressing someone she trusted at the time of the war. It had been going for a good amount of time by then. Also, we know that in real life only a diamond can destroy another diamond. This means that it had to one, be a diamond, and two, be someone that would not care for her. We see that it can not be Yellow or Blue because they are very emotional with Pinks passing. Eyeball does say that it was Rose, as well as all the other Crystal Gems, but Eyeball was the only one to truly see the shattering happen. Pinks Pearl wasn’t there, nor were any quartzes or other warrior Gems. Only Eyeball, and as commonly suggested, Rubies are not the smartest Gems around. Also, she might not of had a great sight of the incident and could easily be lying based on White Diamonds word. There could also be a Gem that can change memories, which could of happend to Eyeball. Also the only Diamond we know nothing about is White. As the most powerful Diamond it would make sense for her to easily cover up the Shattering. White probably only shaw Pink as a competitor or extra resource. Until we learn more about White, I believe that based on the info we have and what logic Zircon gave to use. Roses sword could not of shattered Pink because according to the creator of the sword, Bismuth, It was made to poof a Gem, not shatter. We can also not assume that an attack from Pink could be reflected. White Diamond could of shattered Pink and blamed it on Rose. She then used this as a way to rally more Gems to her cause, and to show their power. By Lying. We could also assume that Pink and Rose wanted to protect earth and without the other Diamonds knowing White Shattered Pink. I do think this theory has ground and good foundation. But until we know more about the Shattering and White Diamonds personality we might not find out. I don’t want this theory to be fully true. It would take away from the message and would start a second war between the diamonds. Plus I want to see all the Diamonds fuse and fight the Temple fusion or some other fusion between all the Crystal Gems, and this would not allow that. But that's just my Theory.