Talk:Sardonyx/@comment-26549409-20150623231201/@comment-26510361-20150625032449

If Rose Quartz was a ruler of Homeworld (which I don't doubt) but chose to go by "Pink Diamond" (which I do doubt), then why would gems that fought FOR Homeworld, such as Jasper, address her as Rose Quartz? First off, if Rose Quartz chose to go under the alias as "Pink Diamond" while on Homeworld, how would the other gems even know her name? Most rulers are secretive and it's unlikely that the other gems would even know her true identity. Also, even if they learned who she really was once she rebelled, it's likely that the gems would still address as "Pink Diamond" out of respect for their former ruler, which Jasper didn't do. And you can't say Jasper lost respect for her bc, in The Return, Jasper said she respected her, even during the rebellion.