Talk:Beta/@comment-26501128-20160806185513/@comment-28288412-20160807215908

1.Amethyst can easily have presumed they were all from homeworld without actually inquiring in depth.

2. People going against the right here in the dirt quote are using pure interpretation also rather than taking the literal interpretation.

3.Also you said yourself that Rose is a liar and has lied to those closest to her. Now considering how early Bismuth came to Earth as a part of the construction project is it impossible that she was present when Rose was actually made or early enough for it to difficult to lie about it? Rose could've lied to Greg.

It could even be a retcon due to the crew changing their minds on a small element of the show.