Talk:Season 5/@comment-32175182-20170714023059

'WHO REALLY'' SHATTERED PINK DIAMOND?! (The most reliable theories I've made.)''' If it was Pink Pearl (or Crystal Gem Pearl)... I think our first suspect is Pink Pearl. Pearls are always with their Diamond, so Pink Diamond's Pearl would've been close to her. When Pink Pearl was mentioned in the court, Yellow and Blue Pearl froze. Some people theorize that Crystal Gem Pearl used to be Pink Pearl, due to her having a Pink Diamond on her spacesuit. Along with the fact that she visited Pink Diamond's Human Zoo before the war, and also because she knew Rose, who was one of Pink Diamond's Gems. If she did used to be Pink Pearl and shattered Pink Diamond, it might be why she reacts so strongly when Steven brings up Pink Diamond. And also why she tries to avoid the topic of which Diamond she used to serve, such as in "Adventures in Light Distortion". Maybe Pearl shapeshifted into Rose to shatter Pink Diamond. That could be why Pearl rarely shapeshifts anymore. Yes, Eyeball did state that she saw Rose shatter Pink Diamond, but she only has one eye, and is not very smart, along with all of the other Rubies, who were tricked by the Crystal Gems several times (Eyeball also believed that Amethyst was Jasper when she shapeshifted into her, so why wouldn't she believe that Pearl was Rose?). Pearl is a good sword fighter. If Pink Diamond was shattered with Rose's Sword (As stated by Blue Diamond in "The Trial"), you could definitely make a connection between the two. If it was Yellow Diamond... A Diamond could easily get close to another Diamond. No Gem would question it. Yellow Diamond acted very stern during the court. She wanted to immediately shatter Rose Quartz. She wanted to close the case before the defense spoke. She was so on edge the whole time. The face she made when Steven said he was guilty was like saying she knows he isn't. In "That Will Be All", she was trying to get Blue over Pink's shattering. She didn't really care for feelings. After the Diamonds got accused for Pinks death, she lost it. She immediately "poofed" both Zircons. Yellow could've also been jealous of Pink Diamond, because Blue was really close to Pink. Yellow really wants to get rid of the Earth, possibly because it was Pink Diamond's one and only colony. Yellow is an obvious choice for Pink's shattering. If it was White Diamond... White Diamond is by far the most mysterious Diamond. We don't even know if her name is actually White Diamond. But we know she exists. There are four colors on The Great Diamond Authority logo; Pink, Yellow, Blue, and White. Each color matches a Diamond. In the Moon Base, there are four murals. Again, Pink, Yellow, Blue, and White. On Homeworld, we got see a glimpse of a silhouette. It's the same shape of White Diamond's mural. If we take a closer look at it, we can see it has a diamond shape on its head. And the whole thing is white. But, there would be a reason they are holding the actual White Diamond back from us. She is the head of Homeworld and The Great Diamond Authority. Quite literally, her gem is on her head. She is the most supreme authority. She is on top of The Great Diamond Authority logo. Her mural is the only one facing foreword. She has many circles around her. I believe this represents all the planets and moons she's conquered. She conquered more than any of the other Diamonds. Pink only has the Earth and it's moon. The most noticeable circle White Diamond has is the one she's holding with both hands. I believe this one represents Homeworld. Real life white diamonds aren't typically referred to as white diamonds. They're just diamonds. They're the purest types of diamonds. In Steven Universe, the Diamonds are the big antagonists, but White Diamond is the boss of them all. She's the major antagonist not just to the Crystal Gems, but the other Diamonds as well. If they step out of line, she will shatter them. She's been foreshadowed since season one, why wait this long to show her unless there was something big going on with her. White was the only Diamond not at the trial. You'd think she wants to find out who shattered Pink, but she didn't, because she already knows. Yellow might know, or be on in it two, but she continued on with the trial for Blue's sake. Yellow was at least there to help with Blue, but White wasn't having any of it. White's the boss; she gets what she wants. Rose's motives for shattering Pink Diamond were pretty clear; Pink owned the Earth and Rose wanted to free it. Perhaps Pink Diamond was getting too attached to the Earth. She was collecting humans, and loving flowers. Gems who have gemstones on their navel are typically nicer. Maybe Pink new what damage colonizing the Earth would do, so she didn't want to go through with it. If the shattered was White Diamond, she would've seen her as soft and maybe a little bit worthless if she didn't go through the colonization. If it was Pink Diamond... Yes, this one seems a bit harsh, (considering that suicide on a kids' show is definitely not a good idea) but it's possible. Pink Diamond could've simply wanted the war to end. Not much is know about Pink's personality, but since her gem is on her navel, we can conclude that she was a nicer Gem. Maybe, she wanted the war to end, so she tried to end it herself by shattering herself. Another Gem could've took the blame for her shattering, or it might've looked like another Gem shattered her by some means. '''Who do you think shattered Pink Diamond? One of the ones listed above or someone completely different?'''