Talk:Rose's Sword/@comment-26233996-20170120075851/@comment-25274978-20170120082002

Bismuth said that Rose's Sword was meant to purely poof a gem and didn't have the capability to shatter the gemstone itself: And Bismuth is the one that made the thing so yeah, hense why Bismuth made the Breaking Point and both Rose and Steven disagreed with it, Steven going so far as to destroy it. So no, the sword wasn't what was used to shatter Pink Diamond... Assuming she is shattered and not just bubbled and locked away in that one chest that is in Lion's mane that we don't know the contents of. Taht is my theory anyway.

PD Fake her death? maybe, PD got bubbled without her wanting to by Rose and those who saw it assumed she was Shattered when seh was not, also possible. PD actually shattered, again possible so many options but the Sword itself was no the tool used to do it.