Thread:LarsMars/@comment-26457410-20151211222304/@comment-28584561-20151212012409

Poorle wrote:

Tsk tsk tsk, you made a straw man judge, misrepresenting my argument isn't going to get you anywhere. The problem is as I said before her plot importance. She was the one who brought Jasper and Peridot to earth in the first place. Their the reason why we have these clusters in the show, which is whats driving the plot forward so far.

As for Ruby and Saphhire I don't really know if they should be consider minor characters or not, but that's not really relevant is it? I never said they couldn't be major characters or minors characters so meh. If i'm completely honest about it, I would classify them as main characters of the show since they fuse into Garnet.

It seems most of you don't want the category on there. That's fine, but most of you are neither right and wrong since the wording of the category is very vague so I guess you have that atleast?

You can't really blame people for misunderstanding your argument when it was very weak and not very well laid out in the first place. All we know about homeworld, the cluster, and YD herself is very vague, we don't even know what relationship each of them has with each other. You're already assuming so much from information that is vague. Because if what the fandom and the show has been hinting us so far, there could be more than one power ruling over homeworld. YD could very well be a major character, but as of this instance, can we classify her as one? Not yet.

Also, was the Ruby and Sapphire comparison really that hard to grasp? Eh not my fault you don't understand so well :P

You seem to have a negative connotation of the phrase "minor character". It neither denotes bad nor good. Most of the minor and major tags are more associated to episode appearance rather than plot importance. Minor characters doesn't mean they contribute little to the plot, they just don't appear that often.