Talk:Evil Spirit Scroll/@comment-20413773-20150724190851/@comment-508329-20150812131151

IMO it would be weird if the worst thing Homeworld ever did to Gems was something that was vaguely hinted at in episode 4 and then never came up again. Garnet reacted to the forced fusion experiments like they were some horrific new thing, like she had no idea that Homeworld could do something to Gems that was so brutal, evil and grimdark. If Gems created the scroll, Garnet would already know that Gems have done worse.

That's why I'm assuming that it was probably made accidetnally by some human who didn't know what the shards really were.