Talk:Rose Quartz/@comment-26462356-20160808210839

Is Rose P.D.?

I don't have a particular opinion one way or the other.

However it is obvious that the Crewniverse is INTENTIONALY leaving that question open. Why else would they carefully avoid letting us see any images of P.D. when they do let us see images of the other diamonds?

It surprises me that people take such adamant positions on the question, on either side.

Really, people, think!

The Crewniverse can do whatever they want. If they want Rose to be P.D. then they will simply find a way to tie up all the information so it fits, like Pearl liking pie.

If they don't want her to be P.D. then they will make that so.

AND NONE OF US KNOWS WHICH IT WILL BE!

That doesn't mean we can't have theories and ideas, it just means that you are engaging in hubris if you think that one theory is more or less likely to be true (unless you can read Rebecca's mind, or have future vision).