Talk:The Great Diamond Authority/@comment-5808856-20160106232509/@comment-20615985-20160107025612

I highly doubt Rose was a Diamond. There are a lot of reasons, but two main ones I'd like to go over right now are:

1.  Every example of the same gem (like Rubies) seems to have the same gem cut as any other. This would also apply to the Diamonds, which have square-cut gemstones (sorry if that isn't the technical term, but you know what I mean).

2.  Every gem of the same type also seems to have similar body structures. Albeit Rose is not "broad-shouldered and intimidating," she is still (presumably) as tall and, well, large as other Quartzes (this actually ties into a theory I have relating to Rose and The Kindergarten, but I digress). The Diamonds are MASSIVE in height, far too tall for Rose, and slender, unlike Rose.

TL;DR:  Gems of the same type are very similar and Rose is like a Quartz, not like the Diamonds at all.