Talk:The Trial/@comment-29005599-20170531214146

I feel that White Diamond is the real culprit here. She's never been seen alongside her "sisters" regarding Pink Diamond maybe because she's too busy. or because she simply doesn't care. Yellow Diamond’s reactions seem to be there to throw us off the trail, or maybe she really did have something to do with Pink Diamond’s shattering, albeit, a small part in it. Diamonds, as we heard in this episode, have supreme authority over one another. So it’s possible WD sent PD’s escorts away to shatter her. PD’s only colonies would have been the earth and the moon, so she must have been a relatively “young” gem compared to her sisters. Maybe WD could tolerate the “off-colors” of YD and BD (because the age difference wasn’t extreme i.e. the number of colonies established), but NOT PD.

Also, real white diamonds reflect/refract light, right? So in this sense, I’d say that WD shattered PD by shapeshifting into a Rose Quartz (as we’ve seen Amethyst do) but because other gems claimed to have “seen” Rose shatter PD but from different viewpoints, could it have just been a trick of angles and light which caused WD to look pink for a bit?

I have a hard time believing that YD could have done so out in the open because her yellow color is such a dead giveaway. But I do believe now, with this episode, that only a diamond could have shattered PD, since the only thing that can break a diamond, is a diamond (as others here have stated). So when the creators focus on the real-life qualities/attributes of the gems we’ve seen so far, couldn’t this be something to consider?



Alas, these are only theories, and I probably missed something that could make these null and void.