Talk:Pink Diamond/@comment-26233996-20170623135109/@comment-32401246-20170710182746

@Jolmev, You made a really good fanfic, but I'll still stick to my theory of PD and Rose having nothing but love for each other. Again, besides what other gems are recounting of what Rose told them, there has been absolutely no evidence to suggest that there was any hate between Rose and PD. The only thing we know of their relationship is that Rose is taking the blame for shattering PD... and even that idea is falling apart. I still believe that the Gem Rebellion on Earth was a rebellion against Homeworld and PD was on the side of the Crystal Gems. This would serve as a motive to why WD had to take her out. Maybe a gem snitched on PD's involvement in the rebellion and that's how WD found out. Diamonds are the leaders of gems, but it appears that WD is the leader of the Diamonds, making her the top dawg. If it got out that she was defied by another Diamond, it would make her look weak or incapable of maintaining control and order. Thus, it was more convenient to just kill PD herself and blame it on the revolters, since that's also a highly believable scenario.

The only reason I stick by this is because PD was revered by her gems as opposed to being worshipped or feared. It doesn't seem like she exercised as much, if any, tyranical or cruel force upon her gems. Additionally, I'm inclined to believe that she was very loving and   kind because the way the zoo was kept, it was in such a way that the humans never had to experience pain, sadness, anger or any of the other negative emotions that people experience through life. I believe she really grew a connection with her colony, the life it contained, and her gems which is something that is actually kind of taboo between diamonds and their subjects. (Think back to the episode when Peridot contacted Yellow Diamond and was treated like a disposable object rather than important.)

So, yeah.