Talk:Beta/@comment-26501128-20160806162043/@comment-25530701-20160808200914

Pretty sure Peridot says that quartzes are made on Earth. Jasper is, Amethyst is, and Rose is HEAVILY implied to be. The Steven Universe crew (Crewniverse) retconned her being made on Homeworld.

And I've heard people using Amethyst's words as "evidence" that she was from Homeworld. Why trust Amethyst when she wasn't even around for the rebellion? She's a very new gem.

Rose lying to Bismuth is just people grasping at straws. Honestly it was already confirmed in the episode that Rose was made on Earth, and in another that Quartzes are made on Earth as well. Why are people still arguing?