Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26695529-20150715212413/@comment-26812261-20150716112435

Renma91 wrote: Thats the thing though, I think Vidalia is a Beach City native, so I doubt Marty and her were dating. I think it was more of a one night stand, for that one night Greg and Marty were in Beach City. Well, we're assuming Marty never went back to Beach City, though it seems like he did, given that Amethyst was seen mimicking an older version of him.

It makes sense, really. The dude was living out of a van with a musician who wasn't making money, but clearly had nothing better to do, seeing as how he kept doing that. Can't imagine his prospects after being ditched by Greg were super great. He probably slinked back into town sometime later, made amends, hung around for a bit, then asshole'd his way out of the picture again. Or just kept in touch with Vidalia for a while after finding out they'd had a kid. Seems like if Sour Cream was born nine months after Story for Steven though, that would make him kinda old, I think.