Talk:Pink Diamond/@comment-28276450-20160925171842/@comment-26292998-20160928193050

They think it for a good reason.

1) Eyeball, a ruby who has been shown to be easily fooled, stated it was the Sword that shattered PD.

2) Bizmuth clearly stated the Sword couldn't shatter, going so far as to have made the Breaking point to do just that Job, something Rose refused to use.

3) Garnet's word isn't really great here cause, well, she wasn't there, she joined after PD was shattered, and so, like the other gems, would believe Rose did it.

4) Rose keeps secrets, Lion, Bizmuth, this one seems like something she's telling people she did, even Pearl.

5) Obviously Amethyst wasn't their either, so from what we know, only Eyeball was there to see it, a Gem who is easily fooled, and could easily mistake a poofing for a shattering, see point 1.

All the evidence points towards PD not being shattered, and theres very clearly something else going on, what's hard to understand about that?

In this case, it's seemed to be a very cunning rouse that a Fact.

The big question is, what really happened?