Thread:Lenhi/@comment-24747384-20160806202127/@comment-24747384-20160806220543

There are no testimonies that Rose is from Earth either, again, just Bismuth's words against Rose' words. You could also argue that ``Here in the dirt´´ could be a methapor to how gems are made, from the dirt and ground. and also, Rose is stated as an Alien by Greg, and she does not negates that fact, and on the same episode, Greg asks:

Greg: Do you... miss your home planet?

Rose: No, never.

Home planet = the planet you came from. if Roses says she does not miss the planet SHE COMES FROM, she can't possibly be from Earth. (and Home planet is not the same as just Home, so the argue of home possibly meaning other thing is invalid).