Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4224349-20150205230904/@comment-25615658-20150212024604

DialgaTheTimeLord wrote: Yoshimickster wrote: I also wonder what kills a gem for real forever, breaking them into shards just makes them mindless automotons but still alive, and mayhaps grinding them into dust would do the same but on a smaller scale. Maybe you'd need to do an anti-magic wave length like that loser in that ice guy's group who got owned super quickly in Fairy Tail. It's possible that even Rose isn't entirely gone, as there's some evidence that highly suggests Rose is part of a fusion that forms Garnet.

I think the painting in "So Many Birthdays" completely disproves that theory that Rose is part of Garnet. If that were true, how could both Garnet and Rose be in the same picture.