Talk:Pink Diamond/@comment-26415383-20180520225047/@comment-24435322-20180522012251

The fact that the crew said no was the main reason that I was not behind this theory. But then again, in retrospect, the statement "her name is Rose Quartz" does not explicitly deny it, but we took it as a no. So they did not really lie in the traditional sense, but there was a lot of misleading and deception.

Also, we relied heavily on exposition from Garnet, who we now know was kept in the dark about the truth, since Amethyst was not even around and Pearl literally could not tell anyone.