Talk:Pink Diamond/@comment-32401246-20170626195903

I think the Gem Rebellion wasn't so much a rebellion against Pink Diamond as it was a rebellion against the Diamond Authority as a whole. I believe Pink Diamond was in on the rebellion on the side of the Crystal Gems, hence why she had to be taken out. I believe that White Diamond is the one who shattered her and used Rose as a scapegoat for the crime. Idk why, but I feel like Rose and Pink Diamond were actually very close. Despite the fact that we've been led to believe that Rose shattered PD, there really hasn't been any evidence of bad blood between them, except for testimony of gems who came into the picture after the fact.

Even though it might seem too obvious if it was really WD who shattered PD, I think Rebecca Sugar could have a backstory behind it that made it so much more appealing. Anyways, these are just my thoughts about it. It doesn't make sense that YD or BD would have been the ones to shatter her since they seem to be the only ones showing any type of grief over her death. Maybe when WD is revealed and we can see her demeanor regarding PD's death, it'll all make sense.