Talk:Pink Diamond/@comment-32175182-20170722122340/@comment-29208650-20170810012108

I say, until we see a body, or in this case fragments, we can't say for certain if Pink diamond was shattered. Most gems made on earth seem to be unusual, defecting from the order of the homeworld, what if Pink diamond got on to the idea of freedom? My point is that in the trial, we heard witnesses saw rose quarts shatter pink diamond, but none were in the trial? Not even Pink Pearl, the loyal attendent and confidant of the victim herself would not stand witness to seek justice? And that is a good question, if Blue diamond wanted to be so close to pink diamond, why wouldn't she take Pink pearl as well?

So, if PD was not shattered, what happened to them? My answer is two indivduals, Fluorite and Rhodinite, Between the two of them they make up eight gems, what I propose is that Pink diamond never left Homeworld the day she was shattered, but she sent the remaining seven gems there they came back, claiming Rose quarts, the leader of an established enemy, was responsible for the alleged death, while Pink diamond hid in the underground. After everything was out there, they all joined PD in the underground and fused. With six other gems, a diamond would be near unrecognizable, except for the gem in a similar placement. Fluorite is such massive that we can't recognize the individual from the whole, finishing PD's escape. As for Rhodonite, it would explain why Rhodonite looks up to Fluorite in the way she does, Rhodonite is made of a Pink Pearl and a Ruby serving under Pink diamond.

As for why Pink diamond would want to leave her position, maybe she was sick of what gems did to other world, it would explain why she would try to preserve humans, but  eventually give up and just try and go into hiding. We see time after time gems struggling to fit the roles of their type, bound by it, almost crippled. Diamonds, massive, are still gems. Everyone thought Rose did it, and Rose never said she did or not as far as we've seen. Maybe to seem more powerful, maybe for morale among the crystal gems, or to avoid all out blame fest. we don't really know. All we know is that the story is falling apart as zircon cast a major shadow of doubt on whether it could be Rose quarts as the murderer if that's the case, and Lars is screwed until we learn the truth about Pink diamond, Fluorite, and Rhodonite.