Talk:Your Mother and Mine/@comment-5406733-20180411181530/@comment-5406733-20180411235816

to CHIDIEStar

That is a big possibility. Though with Garnet's story having Pink Diamond giving out an evil laugh, it's obvious her story isn't 100% accurate.

to Allaedila

Considering Pink Diamond's personality in Jungle Moon and her human-zoo. My guess is that she had Rose help her fake her death. She's obviously not as evil as Garnet made her out to be, and she did have an interest with humans like Rose did. She wouldn't just stop the colonization in fear of disappointing her fellow Diamonds though, which gives her motive to fake her death.

With your third theory, Yellow Diamond would be more likely to have had shattered Pink Diamond than White Diamond. Her behavior in The Trial was very suspicious. Though I don't think any of the Diamonds shatter Pink Diamond and any clues saying so are just red-herrings.

As for Garnet lying. It wouldn't be the first time she's held back the truth from Steven. So I would say the chances of her lying is about 50% possible.