Talk:The Great Diamond Authority/@comment-4165786-20160107210403/@comment-27028809-20160108053443

The problem is: we have confirmation (thanks to Peridot) that the Diamonds are their own breed of gem. I've never suported the idea that Rose is Pink Diamond. Nothing about her being a Diamond makes sense and now that we've seen 2 Diamonds and a better mural depicting them. There is no hope for this theory. As for story, its make for a better underdogish hero for Rose to have been a rebel Quartz. Quartz are the true warriors of Gemkind.

Also her name alone is too spesific to not be a Quartz.