Talk:Yellow Diamond/@comment-26907535-20150822125542

Just another theory... in the first image of Yellow Diamond, just look how huge she is, she is towering over Jasper. Jasper looks to be about the size of Rose. All the visible statues in the sky arena are about the same size, and we now know that one of them is Yellow DIamond, so maybe all the diamonds are that huge? There seems to be a slight correlation between physical size and power in the gem world. I say slight because Lapis is extremely powerful despite her small stature, even overpowering Jasper when fused as Malachite. So there are exceptions. Ruby and Sapphire so far are the smallest gems and are described by Jasper as 'weak gems' (though she clearly has biases and we've seen little of their individual 'powers' when unfused).

So since Rose appears to be on par with Jasper size wise, maybe Rose isn't Pink Diamond, but was more like her general (as Jasper could be for Yellow Diamond). Maybe Pink Diamond died (or was killed) and that prompted Rose's rebellion. Maybe Pink Diamond was trying to save earth too and disagreed with the others diamonds.

I do think more than likely Rose is Pink Diamond, I just don't think it's 'set in stone' (cue Steven laughing over cheesey puns). The clues pointing to Rose as Pink Diamond COULD be red herrings.