Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26198832-20150313123438/@comment-26225030-20150322224143

Themightytyphlosion wrote: I was feeling the same way about the Onion theory. I like it because it's similar to another theory I made a year ago. If it was true and Onion is either Yellow Diamond or her son, then wouldn't have Jasper known about a half-human, half-gem? Also, Onion would've probably been some sort of spy that would report the activities of the Crystal Gems and Steven's existence.

There's quite a few flaws to it that make it impossible I seriously doubt that he's a gem but lets say he turns out to be one..Jasper wouldn't necessarily know because good leaders have to keep secrets from even their closest allies. Do I need to point out which episode proved that? And how would he get back to Yellow Diamond with any information? IF he was a gem I'm pretty sure his kind hearted father tried to put that life behind him but Onion was still evil while prevented to contact with homeworld. But once again..seriously doubt he's a Gem.