Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25539649-20150510212536/@comment-26812261-20150526125913

These claims hold no water. Not to sound pretentious or arrogant, but my Tumblr post debunks the four main misconceptions of the diamonds based on my writting savvy, and I recommend everyone reads it to learn a thing or two about developing your theories. I spent several paragraphs laying out the reasons my claims do, in fact, hold water, and you countered precisely none of it in your response. And as for the blog, "I don't think the writers would do that!" is not a valid rebuttal to fan theories you disagree with, sorry. Fact is, based solely on information in the show, my theory holds just as much water as yours.