Talk:Smoky Quartz/@comment-26891212-20160811165516/@comment-5642360-20160812173045

>>If something implies two opposite things simultaneously then nothing is implied.

Not really applicable here. This would be the case if it was only one person or if it was the entire population that simultaneously believed in the two opposing implications. But a fraction of that said population believes in one, while the other believes the other choice.

Think of it like this, a population of 10 people believed that chocolates can cure cancer and at the same time it worsens cancer. This is because 5 individuals of that population believes in one, while the other five believe in the other.