Talk:Pearl/@comment-30822259-20170104170028/@comment-27793079-20170108064112

I personally believe Pearl was Rose's. The gem placement clearly does not matter, since the leaked Bomb had CG Pearl acting as Saph's pearl. No one questioned why her gem placement wasn't the same as her 'master'. Color defection, now that is an interesting theory, although there hardly is any evidence for both supporting or debunking it. But, I think Pearl's defect is her gem. It's more oval-ish in shape compared to the perfect sphere's the Diamond's pearls have.

And well, Earth was Pink D's planet, so shattering her would still set Pearl free, either 1) She was Pink Pearl, 2) She cut her ties with White D already by joining the Rebellion and thanks to the shattering of Pink D, Earth (and by extent all life, extraterrestrial or not) is free, or 3) Pearl was Rose's, and Rose served under Pink D. If Pink D is dead, Rose serves no one and neither would Pearl.

Also, I believe Rose did shatter Pink D. Think about this; Pearl loved Rose for millenia, she clearly doesn't like to think of her love's most terrible deed. And she was willing to die for Rose; there is no way she would let Rose be called a shatterer if she didn't shatter.