Board Thread:Ask the Staff/@comment-26443965-20150530233353/@comment-23880286-20150531173943

I have a disambiguation problem as well, with Steven's Shield. It's a problem because the object doesn't have its own page, but is in the Gem Weapons page instead.

There's basically three options I think.

1. Create a disambig page on Steven's Shield, with one link going to Gem Weapons#Rose's/Steven's Shield and one to the soundtrack. The disadvantage is that most people won't be looking for the soundtrack when they're looking for Steven's Shield, so it's probably better to make Steven's Shield go directly to the object, which brings us to two.

2. Create a redirect page on Steven's Shield to Gem Weapons#Rose's/Steven's Shield. The disadvantage of this is that the people who are looking for the soundtrack won't be able to find it. A solution to this is to put "This is about the object, for the soundtrack see here." at the top of the section, but that will look weird to people who are just browsing the Gem Weapons page, and didn't get redirected from the Steven's Shield page.

3. Move Steven's Shield (Song) to Steven's Shield because there's no other page named Steven's Shield. The disadvantage of this is the same as 1. Most people won't be looking for the soundtrack, but for the object. So this is not really a logical thing to do.

So, what should be done here?

Speaking of Steven's Shield page, there should probably be redirects from Pearl's Spear, Garnet's Gauntlets, Amethyst's Whip etc. to the Gem Weapons sections as well by the way. I might do that once I know what to do with Steven's Shield.