<p>Remember in Back To The Moon, where the crystal gems travel to the moon base with the rubies? And when Eyeball said "I was there. I saw it with my own eye. I watched the leader of the Crystal Gems -- Rose Quartz -- shatter Pink Diamond!". ? </p><p>But what if Rose didn't shatter P.D, What if Eyeball was lied to or saw things differently </p><p>Because here are some things I remember about the Rubies in the episode Hit The Diamond </p><p>1. They're stupid 2. They're gullible 3. They'll listen to anything </p><p>These reasons lead me to believe that Rose NEVER shattered P.D. but yes, I know Eyeball was there during the war but still..... she's a Ruby, she's dumb. </p><p>There are theories about Pink Diamond being Lion but that may not be possible </p><p>But, What if P.D was Poofed and Bubbled. Bismuth said Rose's sword is incapable of shattering a gem, but to destroy the form. Eyeball said this about her sword "Who cares about her shield? Her huge sword is what I remember." Eyeball might've thought Rose shattered P.D. </p><p>But still these are my thoughts about this discussion about Pink Diamond's death </p>