Even tho lapis’s blank eyes were creepy. The fact that amethyst was rly close to shattering, and the backwards talk that happened rly shook me. Eyeball was just smol

^ Pretty much this. Amethyst seemed incredibly damaged in a way that just got progressively worse, and even though she took it pretty well, it was really disturbing. Lapis's damage seems minor in comparison, especially since we first saw her cracked and didn't know what she was supposed to look like. Eyeball's body phasing in and out was pretty freaky, though.