<div class="quote"><i>Femslash-addict wrote:
I share sentiments with FinestFantasyVI, because the "PD is good" theories come out contrived.
<div class="quote">Pink Diamond was bratty before getting her own colony and was evil but whe she colonized Earth, She got happier and less evil.</i></div>
What makes you think she wasn't "happy" at the time of <i>Jungle Moon</i>? Amethyst is always getting into arguments with Pearl, and sometimes Garnet, but she was only ever unhappy for a prolonged period when Jasper told her she was defective. Pink had an argument with Yellow, and got angry like Amethyst did when Garnet and Pearl reprimanded her for her juvenile behavior (<i>Tiger Millionaire</i>). Also, a jovial disposition doesn't equate to becoming sympathetic toward Earth's creatures or the CGs.
<p>
</p>
<div class="quote"><i>Then she developed love for humans</i></div>
Where is this coming from? What evidence have we seen in the show to support this hypothesis? A strong theory cites evidence for contextual support; without evidence, it is just wishful thinking.
<p>
</p>
<div class="quote"><i>When Yellow found out she wanted to save the humans, Yellow got mad and BOOM! Yellow shattered Pink after an argument.</i></div>
This statement is by far the most compelling, as we've seen violent altercations involving Yellow, suggesting an aggressive tendency.
<p>
</p>
<div class="quote"><i>Eyeball was an eye witness right? Well, not really. She just came to say something to pink and Rose was called by PD to talk to her about something,</i></div>
Interesting idea, but I don't see why she would report to Pink directly. Pink was not her Diamond, and given Rubies' position in the Gem hierarchy, it seems more plausible that Eyeball would instead report to a Gem in Pink's guard or entourage. Someone suggested Eyeball might have been at the seen as a bodyguard for one of Pink's elites, which would explain how she could have witnessed the shattering.
<p>
</p>
<div class="quote"><i>Why did BD say she was very close to PD when she died?</i></div>
Blue did not say this.
<table class="wikitable bgrevo"><tr><th style="font-family:nunito;">Blue Diamond
</th><td>How curious. I'm impressed by humanity's ability to survive in the wild. What a strange planet. Where else would a being as fragile as a human live, while a being as powerful as a Diamond, perish? This is where it happened, where she was broken.
</td></tr><tr><th style="font-family:nunito;">Greg
</th><td>Were you close?
</td></tr><tr><th style="font-family:nunito;">Blue Diamond
</th><td>Very.
</td></tr><tr><th style="font-family:nunito;">Greg
</th><td>I-I'm awfully sorry. I know how hard it is to move on when you've lost someone.
</td></tr></table><p>The word "close" refers to Blue's relationship with Pink, not where Blue was at the time of the shattering. Frankly, we don't know where she was when Pink was shattered, and if we assume she didn't shatter Pink herself, then I'd like to imagine she was not nearby, otherwise she should've prevented it. Neither Yellow nor Blue could rationalize why Pink's entourage and/or guard did not act efficiently when Pink was shattered, which more than likely suggests the Diamonds <i>weren't </i>there, or are lying as a coverup.
</p><p>I believe the purpose of the episode Jungle Moon was more than just to provide insight on Pink's relationship with Yellow, and how Pink might've looked and acted. You bring up a great point about this occurring <i>before</i> Pink acquired Earth, and likely any Gems for that matter, because something must've <i>changed</i> for Yellow or the other Diamonds to <i>give/allow </i>Pink Earth and her own Gems. This episode established a temperament for Pink, something at her core that <i>wouldn't change</i>, but perhaps signified a point in time that <i>motivated</i> Pink to act more like her fellow Diamonds.
</p>
</div>
<p>Oh, Well I'm dumb.
</p>