Vote: Should we split the Gem Homeworld page?

742mph·7/25/2017 in Wiki Voting

Currently, the Gem Homeworld page contains information both on the physical planet called "Homeworld" and on Homeworld Gem society, which is also present on Homeworld's colony planets. I propose moving Gem Homeworld's society information (including caste system, technology, and social norms) to a new page, leaving Gem Homeworld to be about the planet itself and its history.

For reference, here ([1]) is the current Gem Homeworld page, and here ([2]) is an edit of mine that should give you a good idea of what Gem Homeworld would look like with the proposed changes.

Support: Create a new page for information on Homeworld Gem society (including caste system, technology, and social norms) across their empire as a whole. Make the Gem Homeworld page only about the planet called "Homeworld."

Oppose: Do not create a new page. Continue describing both Homeworld (the planet) and Homeworld Gem society on the Gem Homeworld page.

My stance: Support

(Edited by 742mph)

大ファン·7/25/2017

Neutral I always thought it was weird that gem castes are described in great detail on two different articles anyway. The gem homeworld page and the gems page. Maybe if you remove the caste info from the homeworld page, it won't even need a new page because it's already on the gems page.

(Edited by 大ファン)

CHIDIEStar·7/29/2017

Neutral, incase if there's opposes. I'm just naive.

(Edited by CHIDIEStar)

AquaticPanic·7/29/2017

Oppose It's kinda like talking about a corporation's structure but not how it works.

(Edited by AquaticPanic)

Sophiedp·7/29/2017

Oppose

(Edited by Sophiedp)

Jolmev·7/30/2017

Oppose We would get "Gem Homeword" and "Homeworld Gems" that's confusing, also, the Homeworld gems described as it's society has been done great :B, like CrystalMomSquad and AquaticPanic said

(Edited by Jolmev)

SugarKitten57·7/30/2017

I support this, but I do not know how to make the cute little plus sign.?

(Edited by SugarKitten57)

Jolmev·7/30/2017

SugarKitten57 wrote:
I support this, but I do not know how to make the cute little plus sign.?

When you are commenting, down with the buttons to insert images an stuff, there's this symbol "[ ]" click on it and insert what says on this page then you can click the one with the eye to continue commenting or just write there

(Edited by Jolmev)

Fencery·7/30/2017

Oppose

(Edited by Fencery)

Tomas i.s.d.·8/2/2017

大ファン wrote: Neutral I always thought it was weird that gem castes are described in great detail on two different articles anyway. The gem homeworld page and the gems page. Maybe if you remove the caste info from the homeworld page, it won't even need a new page because it's already on the gems page.

I agree with this, redundancy can be a great problem for wikis. So Neutral

(Edited by Tomas i.s.d.)

Jolmev·8/2/2017

Tom Topaz wrote:

I agree with this, redundancy can be a great problem for wikis. So

Neutral

I change my vote to Neutral this is right, both pages say the same stuff, so either summarize or edit that

Splitting the gem homeworld page is now a worse idea lol

(Edited by Jolmev)

What do you think?