FANDOM


  • I've always wondered who would win in a fight, Garnet or Opal? Separately, both Amethyst and Pearl are no match for Garnet, something even Rebecca Sugar agrees with (check her reddit). But what about if Pearl and Amethyst fused into Opal? Opal is super powerfull, graceful, and fast. Garnet is strong, focused, and has future vision. Not to mention, a stable fusion. So, who do you think would win?

      Loading editor
    • I lean towards Opal if she can stay fused. It would be Garnet's vuture vision vs's Opal's mobility & long range. Up close garnet can smash  but If Opal gets some distance and I think she could, she would outmaneuvr Garnet for the win.  

        Loading editor
    • Garnet, because she is not only faster, stronger, tougher, and more agile; she can stay fused underpressure.

        Loading editor
    • Garnet might be physically stronger but I doubt she is faster or more agile. Opal had excellent strength and mobility in Giant Woman (punching through giant bird, jumping across chasm, graceful & rapid dodging and movement) to the point where I think she could outmanuever Garnet. Opal keeps her distance and rains down arrows for the win. 

      It would be close especially since Garnet is so durable and has future vision. Opal would have to find a way to stay fused. 

        Loading editor
    • Opal's weapon only provide support at long ranges, which at times and places is hard to find, i.e. no all ways reliable.  Gauntles, however can be used in hand-to-hand and a long range.

        Loading editor
    • Actually Opal summoned both Amethyst's weapon and Pearl's (even fancy spinning pearls) before she fused them into a bow, similar to how Sugilite made her flail. So Opal can use the whip and spear independenlty and masterfully.  Yes Garnet can fire off her gaunlets  but the range and power from that move doesn't compare to Opal's bow.

        Loading editor
    • Just becuase Opal has both weapons, does not mean that she has mastery over them, as they are not her weapons.

        Loading editor
    • Hackmanite wrote:
      I lean towards Opal if she can stay fused. It would be Garnet's vuture vision vs's Opal's mobility & long range. Up close garnet can smash  but If Opal gets some distance and I think she could, she would outmaneuvr Garnet for the win.  

      I completely agree... Especially with that bow of hers, i think thats the only way opal can win as long ass she has that distance... But if she cant get away Garnet has a really good chance since she's head on.

        Loading editor
    • Owenbretts wrote: Just becuase Opal has both weapons, does not mean that she has mastery over them, as they are not her weapons.

      Yes, they are. Amethyst and Pearl are both skilled with their weapons, thus making Opal a prodigy. :V

        Loading editor
    • I think Opal is a master or at least very proficient with whip/spear. Fusions seem to keep if not amplify the abilities they had as seperate gems. Malachite kept Lapis's hydrokenisis, Opal kept if not amplified Pearl's grace and skill. Again Opal fancy spinned Pearl's sword briefly. 

      Agreed Garnet is a head on monster. Close quarters battle between the two would be epic.

        Loading editor
    • Hackmanite wrote: I think Opal is a master or at least very proficient with whip/spear. Fusions seem to keep if not amplify the abilities they had as seperate gems. Malachite kept Lapis's hydrokenisis, Opal kept if not amplified Pearl's grace and skill. Again Opal fancy spinned Pearl's sword briefly. 

      Agreed Garnet is a head on monster. Close quarters battle between the two would be epic.

      Wow, I never thought of fusions amplifying the component gems' powers and weapon proficiency. That's a great point!

        Loading editor
    • Yeah, every fusion doesn't just fuse their weapons, they can use them separately. Sugilite could just use Garnet's gauntlets or just Amethyst's whip.


      As for Opal vs Garnet, well it's going to be hard. Garnet can easily dodge attacks cause future vision, but Opal is way faster than Garnet.

        Loading editor
    • ThetisPL wrote:
      Yeah, every fusion doesn't just fuse their weapons, they can use them separately. Sugilite could just use Garnet's gauntlets or just Amethyst's whip.


      As for Opal vs Garnet, well it's going to be hard. Garnet can easily dodge attacks cause future vision, but Opal is way faster than Garnet.

      Yeah it is a tough choice but im still pretty sure Opal would win.

        Loading editor
    • I think the outcome could change as the series goes on. As Pearl and Amethyst's relationship becomes more trustful and close, they should be able to not defuse under much circumstances.

        Loading editor
    • Probably Garnet. She has a more stable relationship, and can thus be a fusion even under pressure. She's also comparable as far as speed and agility go, has the strength advantage, and is the more skilled unarmed combatant.

        Loading editor
    • this would most likely nver happen, no offense

        Loading editor
    • Opal and garnet will tie because they are both fuison

        Loading editor
    • Sunnydacat66 wrote: this would most likely nver happen, no offense

      I never said it would happen. I'm just curious as to who would win in a fight.

        Loading editor
    • http://steven-universe.wikia.com/wiki/Gem_Cave_Creature

      Where is everyone getting the idea that Opal is so much faster than Garnet? Do you remember her fight with the gem cave creature in Arcade Mania? Her speed, and skill, in that fight is top fricken notch. I urge you to rewatch it and reconsider. Giant Woman is one of my favorite episodes of the serious and I think underneath Jail Break I have watched it most. Garnet can not only dodge but deflect projectiles at high speeds. Individually I doubt that Opal's arrows are lethal, it's as a barrage that they have strength. Garnet has the sense and skill to avoid/deflect most of those arrows and close the gap between her and Opal. Jasper was somewhat even with her in close combat but Garnet fought with much more clean moves and brains. Garnet is just too good.

        Loading editor
    • Away from being able to stay fused:

      Garnet And Opal

      Speed: Garnet = Opal

      Evasiveness: Garnet < Opal

      Strength: Garnet > Opal

      Accuracy: Garnet < Opal 

      Intelligence: Garnet > Opal  (Pearl and Amethyst tend to fight often)

      Stability: Garnet > Opal


      Results:

      Close Combat: Garnet

      Mid-Combat:Garnet

      Far Combat: Opal

      Overall Winner:Garnet

        Loading editor
    • GW - OpalGIF

      Opal keeps her distance Garnet is poofed~

        Loading editor
    • Sticks the Badger wrote:
      GW - OpalGIF
      Opal keeps her distance Garnet is poofed~

      If she has enough time to charge her shot

      but garnet can still dodge it

      Opal wins in far combat

      But the overall winner is still garnet

        Loading editor
    • Okay...why does Garnet lose in "evasiveness"? or "accuracy"?

      Let me say that I'm fairly certain we've seen everything Pearl and Amethyst have to offer combat-wise. If Ruby has heat/fire power and Sapphire has ice power...then we still have to see everything Garnet can do.

        Loading editor
    • Garnet, she's stronger, and Ruby and Sapphire are 'used to' being fused. So Garnet most likely has more combat experience and generally a stabler fusion since Ruby and Sapphire are almost always Garnet. 

        Loading editor
    • Should Make a thread about amethyst vs sardonyx

      We've already seen pearl vs sugilite. i think i we all know who would win in garnet vs opal now

        Loading editor
    • PicsArt 1434653217372

      Rainbow Quartz~

      Screen Shot 2015-06-18 at 11.45.27 AM

      Garnet~

      VS.






      I'mma bet on 19px-.png

        Loading editor
    • it's kinda obvious that Garnet would win. not only because she has more experience and her future vision ability, but also because Garnet is an extreamly stable fusion where as Opal unfused after she forgot something so maybe opal she some how got Garnet to unfuse but that is very unlikely.

        Loading editor
    • I think it would be an evenly matched battle because:

      1. They both have long range and short range weapons

      2. Pearl's grace and precision combined with Amethest's unprdictability and thinking on her feet would make Opal harder to predict with Garnet's future vision

      3. Garnet is head-on to a fault whilst Opal is analytical and head-on E.X. --- Garnet would charge right in when her future vision tells her what a good oportunity would be, but Opal would go to attack after she has the plan thought out. Garnet would prdict what Opal would do before she does it.

        

        Loading editor
    • I think it's still a little too soon to decide who would win bc we've had one+ seasons with Garnet as opposed to two episodes with Opal. All we've seen her do is jump around and shoot arrows; we don't know the extent of her abilities. And, also, all we've really seen is the Pearl side of Opal, not the Amethyst side of her. We also don't know how she would fare in hand-to-hand but she would probably be able to preform really well bc Amethyst is strong and Pearl is agile and when put together, those two attributes can create a powerhouse. But I would legit pay money to see Rainbow Quartz go head to head with Garnet, and, going off of the fact that Rose could probably take Garnet solo, I would have to say RQ for the win. 

        Loading editor
    • Under the assumption that Opal would manage to stay fused for the entire fight, I'm leaning more towards her than Garnet, but I'm also incredibly biased in that out first giant woman is my favorite woman, giant or otherwise. >///>

        Loading editor
    • GARNET DEFINENTLY!

      Opal's weapon is used for range. Garnet's weapon is used for close combat BUT can also be used for range as show in "Watermelon Stevens" and "Reformed." Opal defused over a simple mission that she didn't complete. Garnet would never fuse for a reason like that because she is more stable. 

      Another reason, Opal would have to charge before firing or else her aim would be less accurate and weaker so Garnet would have enough time to use her future vision. Plus Garnet just fires without having to charge. Even if Opal would try to hit Garnet with an arrow, Garnet can obviously deflect it with her gauntlets. 

      I'm all in for Garnet.

        Loading editor
    • why would they fight in the firts place

        Loading editor
    • Pansey2015 wrote:
      why would they fight in the firts place

      Why wouldn't they fight? It could be for practice or something.

        Loading editor
    • So Garnet will be punching the arrow.

        Loading editor
    • Even Opal don't agree with each other.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.