Kind people can still shatter someone if they needed to and Rose needed to in order to save the Earth, it doesn't make her bad it just means that she had to make a hard choice

But pink diamond is not evil she Creted human.If pink diamound not evil then what do this make Ross??.That last episodes have made qustion ever thing it like we be lie by Garnet she tell us all lie and that backstroy was a lie.Someone is lie who is it,It hard to add up this logic.Poor Steven :( lol.

I Start to think that gem where reCode to go with Ross.

Pink Diamond didn't create humans, she took them as trophies for her conquest. How much of the recent Steven Bomb did you pay attention to?

Was that the zoo talk about and not earth.It still not very clear where the human come for yet.

Okay, let's set things clear:

Rose Quartz was a pacifistic terrorist. she led the Rebellion, and although she was against shattering gems, events unfolded that resulted in Rose shattering Pink Diamond for the good of the Earth, whether she intended to shatter or not. if this was before the creation of the Breaking Point, then this was the catalyst for why she would never shatter again.

Ross isn't real- I cannot stress this enough. When a character makes a hard choice, their actions speak volumes about their character. it makes them layered. Rose's decision to shatter Pink Diamond- if we ever learn the full story about that, will say much more about Rose Quartz than Pearl, Garnet, Jasper and Greg ever could. We've been seeing Ideals of Rose from other characters- we know her as they want to know her.

I'm going to tell you a little something about Abraham Lincoln now. See, Lincoln is known as the man who fought a war to unify the United States, free the slaves, and make slavery an illegal practice. Most Americans know this. However, most of them are unaware of what Lincoln wanted to do afterwards (And never did as a result of being assassinated): See, Lincoln wasn't actually all that fond of Black People himself, he just agreed that it wasn't right to own them and force them to work on the plantations. As soon as the slaves were freed, Lincoln wanted to round them all up and ship them back to Africa, which depending on your views could be either good or bad, but I doubt we'd be living in the same kind of world today if this had transpired. and yet, History glorified Lincoln. Lincoln is seen as the greatest president of all time.

Garnet and Pearl glorified Rose, shoving the shattering of Pink Diamond under the rug. Jasper demonized Rose, focusing entirely on said shattering and her defection from Homeworld.

There is no "Second Rose/Ross"- There are simply many people who see Rose Quartz for many things.

RidleyKraid187  I love you comments and it great logic.Yes Lincoln fit with Rose quartz very well in the stroy. 

Still rebecca sugar say the no one evil in steven universe so I have to take that as facts ever if it very hard to beleven in that in this shows.If that is facts I can not say Pink Diamond is evil if the no one evil in steven universe.Still this lincoln fit in nice in Steven universe.

I agree with what Ridley K said. Eliminating what has been shown and told of Rose so far (by the other characters, by other evidence shown to Steven e.g. the casette tape) would undermine the storytelling choices made in the show and just wouldn't feel like a pay-off. As a fan, I would be neutral about it but I'd definitely feel a bit cheated. There have been so many clues left by the show and they all point to the fact that Rose Quartz was more complex as a gem and person than what we were first shown. Even if the facts seem conflicting I think we'll find out what happened with Pink Diamond and Rose. It's internal conflict for Steven too but I want to believe the crew is stringing this together deliberately so we can feel for the characters and learn something from the experience of watching this show.

If Rose(the Rose who led the rebellion & shattered PD and the Rose who spent all this time with the remaining Crystal Gems) was two Rose Quartzes it would make much less sense with the info we've been given thus far, so lets wait and see. Of course it's interesting to posit this sort of stuff, especially after seeing so many bubbled RQ gems but. Honestly it doesn't quite add up that there would be two gems, but anything could happen, it could be allusion to something else altogether and maybe in some roundabout way your theory could be revealed as some truth. But lets wait until the next clues about the history of the rebellion. Let the crew finish the arcs they've set up. We also don't know the exact details behind the shattering itself (it's still been a bit vague so far beyond "Pink Diamond was shattered and is not coming back" so we just need to wait for more secrets revealed.

Thank man and I wait for the secrets revealed what ever it going it going be very sad stroy ya.

I no allow used this theory anymore Lincoln therory work better.

I try to get into Steven head beause me and steven we both use logic.To have good logic you have remove every thing you knows and look at it from a new way.Lots I do as job is look at business topology and make software but sometime you have to remove the old business  topology if what to make something new and better and you have to talk to real people ask them what software you want.My jobs have lots of logic and look at lots of the business topology and each time kill samll bit of my soul.This why I do steven universe theory it give me break and make me human again and not a bot "You do not want to hear me talk like a bot LOL" 

I also think of do a new theory when Steven is dyslexia like me but hide it.I re-watch check all time Steven was write somethink and check how long it take him.It take him 30 secound before he write his own name it look like it was very hard for him ): .This theory might take some time.

Well, good luck with working on your theories.

I must be dyslexic because I can't understand this writing.